323. Why “Hire Slow, Fire Fast” Is Terrible Advice for Dental Practice Owners

Firing a team member is one of the most uncomfortable parts of owning a dental practice — and according to Dr. Matt Vogt, most of the advice out there makes it harder, not easier.

In this episode, Matt takes apart the popular “hire slow, fire fast” cliché and shares a real coaching conversation with a client who recently acquired a practice. The client inherited a front office where four team members had no clear roles and no defined expectations — including “Kathy,” an employee who’d been shuffled from position to position for years without ever being told what a good job actually looked like.

When the team pushed for Kathy to be let go, the client’s gut said the same. But Matt’s coaching reframed the situation: before you fire someone, you owe it to them — and to yourself as a leader — to give your absolute best effort. That means clear roles, clear expectations, real training, and honest accountability.

Dr. Matt’s core philosophy: people fire themselves. When you’ve laid everything out on the table, and someone still can’t rise to the standard, the decision becomes clear, guilt-free, and fair. And the bonus? The better you get at creating clarity, the less often you’ll ever need to fire anyone.

Key takeaways:

  • “Hire slow, fire fast” skips the leadership work that actually solves the problem
  • Underperformance is often a symptom of unclear roles, not a bad employee
  • Trust your gut on fit — but do the systems work before deciding
  • Give underperformers a genuine, well-defined chance to succeed
  • Clarity removes the anxiety and second-guessing from firing
  • Systemize your office, and you’ll rarely reach the firing point

Ready to build a practice — and a team — that runs on clarity? Take the free lifestyle and practice assessment and start a no-pressure conversation with Derek, Matt, Steve, or Raheel.

 

Connect with us:

Ready to elevate your practice?

Take the first step towards transforming your dental practice.

Get your free copy of our resources or schedule a consultation with one of our coaching experts today.

Are YOU Interested?

Drs. Williams, Van De Graaff, Vogt and Haider work with motivated dentists who want to improve their work/life balance, increase their net income, and take their life and practice to a higher level. If you’re interested in working with us, please fill out this short survey and we will email you some thoughts based on your situation directly to your inbox.